How to Start a Book Club That Doesn't End in Literary Warfare (And Other Success Stories)
So you want to start a book club? Congratulations! You're about to embark on a journey that's part intellectual adventure, part social experiment, and part exercise in diplomatic immunity. I've started two and both are still thriving. Think of it as forming a small nation where the only currency is opinions about character development and everyone's a critic.
Step 1: Assemble Your Literary Avengers
First things first—you need people. But not just any people. You need the right people. This isn't like assembling a fantasy football team where you can trade Karen from down the street if she keeps picking romance novels when everyone agreed on sci-fi. Choose wisely.
The Golden Rule of Member Selection: Aim for 6-8 people maximum. Any fewer and you'll feel like you're hosting an awkward dinner party. Any more and you'll spend half the meeting just figuring out whose turn it is to talk. Think of it as the Goldilocks principle of group dynamics.
Look for people who:
- Actually read books (shocking requirement, I know)
- Can disagree without staging a dramatic exit
- Show up to things they commit to
- Won't judge you for ugly-crying over fictional characters
Step 2: Democracy vs. Dictatorship: Choosing Your Leadership Style
Every book club needs a benevolent dictator—sorry, "facilitator. " This person keeps discussions on track, sends reminder texts, and occasionally has to say things like, "Yes, we get it, you hated the ending, but can we please move on to literally anything else?"
Pro tip: Rotate facilitating leadership monthly. This prevents any one person from going full literary tyrant and ensures everyone gets a chance to experience the unique joy of herding cats who have opinions about metaphors.
Step 3: The Great Format Debate
Meeting Frequency: Finding Your Rhythm
Monthly meetings are the sweet spot. It gives everyone enough time to actually read the book (revolutionary concept) without losing momentum. Weekly meetings turn reading into homework, and quarterly meetings make you forget you're even in a book club.
Location, Location, Location
- Someone's home: Cozy, personal, and free. Downside: someone has to clean their house and provide snacks.
- Coffee shop: Public accountability (harder to start screaming about plot holes). Downside: competing with the espresso machine during dramatic readings.
- Library: Very meta. Also free. Downside: you have to whisper your passionate debates about whether the protagonist deserved redemption.
- Virtual: Perfect for when life happens. Downside: someone will inevitably forget to mute themselves during bathroom breaks.
Step 4: The Art of Book Selection (Without Starting Wars)
This is where things get spicy. Everyone has opinions, and those opinions will clash like literary gladiators in an arena made of post-it notes and strong feelings.
Strategies that actually work
- Democratic voting
Create a list, vote on it. Simple and fair, and occasionally results in reading something nobody really wanted. - Theme months
Mystery March, Romance September, "Books That Make Us Question Our Life Choices" November. - The hat method
Everyone suggests a book, names go in a hat. It's like literary roulette, but with less risk of financial ruin. - The veto system
Anyone can suggest, but everyone gets one veto per year. Use them wisely.
Books to avoid unless you enjoy chaos
- Anything over 800 pages (unless you're all retired, unemployed or have given up on sleep)
- Extremely controversial topics during holiday seasons
- Books that require a PhD to understand (save Ulysses for when you really want to watch friendships crumble)
Step 5: Mastering the Art of Discussion
Here's where your book club either becomes a sophisticated salon of literary discourse or devolves into a wine-fueled argument about whether the author's use of blue curtains really represents depression.
Discussion ground rules:
- No spoilers for people who aren't finished (obviously, but you'd be surprised)
- Respect different opinions (even when someone thinks Twilight is high literature)
- Stay on topic for at least 75% of the meeting
- The popcorn rule: Everyone gets to talk before anyone goes twice
Conversation starters that actually work:
- "What surprised you most about this book?"
- "Which character would you absolutely not want to be stuck in an elevator with?"
- "If this were turned into a movie, what would Hollywood definitely ruin?"
Step 6: The Snack Situation
Let's be honest—half the reason people show up is for the food. Embrace this. Work with it. The path to a successful book club is paved with good snacks and adequate caffeine.
Snack strategy options:
- Potluck style
Everyone brings something. Chaos, but delicious chaos. - Themed snacks
Reading a book set in Italy? Time for pasta night. - Simple and consistent
Same person brings the same thing every time. Boring but reliable. - No-snack club
This is book club hard mode. Only attempt if your group has the discipline of monks.
Step 7: Handling the Inevitable Drama
Every book club will face challenges. People will have strong opinions. Someone will hate a book everyone else loved. Gary will keep bringing up that one novel from three months ago that nobody else remembers. Here's how to handle it:
When someone dominates discussion
Implement a talking stick (or spoon, or rubber chicken—whatever works).
When nobody likes the book
Lean into it! Sometimes the best discussions come from collectively roasting a terrible novel.
When someone hasn't read the book
Have a backup plan. Maybe they can just listen, or better yet, assign them to bring extra snacks as penance.
When personal drama spills over
Gently redirect to the book. "Speaking of betrayal, let's talk about Chapter 12..."
Step 8: Keeping the Magic Alive
Mix things up occasionally:
- Author visits (virtual or in-person)
- Book-to-movie nights
- Genre challenges
- Field trips to literary landmarks (or just the bookstore)
Celebrate your milestones:
- First anniversary party
- 25th book celebration
- "Worst book we've ever read" awards ceremony
Stay flexible: Your book club will evolve. Embrace the changes, roll with the punches, and remember that the best book clubs are the ones where people actually want to show up.
The Secret Ingredient
Here's the thing nobody tells you about starting a book club: it's not really about the books. Sure, books are the excuse that brings everyone together, but what you're really creating is a space for connection, discussion, and the kind of friendships that can survive passionate disagreements about unreliable narrators.
The best book clubs are the ones where people feel comfortable being themselves—whether that's the person who takes detailed notes in the margins, the one who always relates everything back to their own life, or the one who shows up just for the social time and admits they skimmed the last fifty pages.
So go forth and create your literary empire. Start small, stay flexible, and remember: the worst book club meeting is still better than no book club meeting. And if all else fails, you can always blame everything on the author.
Now stop reading blog posts about book clubs and go start one already. Those books won't discuss themselves.
Comments