Mad Mabel BOOK REVIEW

• Date Published:
  April, 2026
• Length:
  352 pages—Listening Time: 9 hours 20 minutes
• Genre:
  Fiction, Historical Fiction
• Setting:
  Present day, Melbourne, Australia
• Awards
  New England Society Book Award Winner Fiction 2025;
  Lariat Adult Fiction Reading List Selection 2025; All Connecticut Reads 2025; Mid-Continent Public Library Best Books Audiobooks 2024
• Languages:
  English
• Sensitive Aspects:
  Childhood bullying and social ostracism, emotional abuse by a parent, domestic violence, parental cruelty, suicide of a parent, depiction of a sociopathic parent, traumatic death of a sibling, child conviction and imprisonment for murder, discussion of multiple suspicious deaths, mental health stigma and the “mad” label, gaslighting and malicious gossip by family and community, marginalization of an accused child, threats of violence toward neighbors, strong or vulgar language, references to sexual content and adult relationships, depictions of trauma and long-term psychological impact, and general themes of injustice and victim-blaming toward a young girl and an elderly woman
• Movie:
  As of May 2026, there has been no official announcement of a movie adaptation for Mad Mabel.
• Recommended for Book Club:
  Yes!

If you thought you’d already met the most unforgettable curmudgeon in fiction, think again—because Mabel is about to walk in, take a seat, and completely steal the show.

Move over, Ove. Mabel is here.

At first glance, Mad Mabel sounds like the kind of neighborhood legend you politely avoid—the woman everyone whispers about, the one with strong opinions, sharper comebacks, and absolutely no interest in making you comfortable. But Sally Hepworth doesn’t just introduce us to a “difficult” older woman. She hands us a character who is messy, hilarious, stubborn, deeply human—and impossible not to love.

And here’s the thing: within just a few pages, I wasn’t avoiding Mabel—I was rooting for her.

Hepworth has a knack for taking familiar tropes and flipping them on their head, and she does it brilliantly here. What begins as a story about an eccentric older woman quickly unfolds into something much richer: a layered exploration of loneliness, grief, memory, and the quiet ways people hold on (or let go). Mabel may be prickly, but she’s also perceptive in ways that cut straight to the truth—sometimes painfully so.

You know that feeling when a character feels so real you could swear you’ve met them before? That’s Mabel. She reminded me of that one neighbor, that distant relative, maybe even a future version of myself—the one who says exactly what everyone else is too polite to admit.

And yet, beneath all the sharp edges, there’s a tenderness that sneaks up on you.

What makes Mad Mabel truly shine isn’t just its unforgettable protagonist—it’s the way the story balances humor with genuine emotional depth. One moment you’re laughing at Mabel’s brutally honest observations, and the next, you’re quietly heartbroken by what lies underneath them.

I went into this expecting a charming character study. I came out of it completely captivated.

Nine stars, no hesitation.

So if you’re in the mood for a story that will make you laugh, pause, reflect, and maybe even call someone you’ve been meaning to check on—Mad Mabel is ready to meet you.

Mad Mabel follows Elsie Mabel Fitzpatrick, an eighty-one-year-old woman living on the same quiet Melbourne street, Kenny Lane, that she’s called home for sixty years. To her neighbors, she’s simply Elsie: a prickly, nosy, fiercely independent older woman with a sharp tongue, a hot cup of tea always in hand, and very little patience for small talk. What almost no one on Kenny Lane knows is that decades earlier, under her real name, Mabel Waller, she was at the center of a sensational crime as Australia’s youngest convicted murderer.

The story unfolds in a dual timeline, moving between “Then” and “Now.” In the present, the calm of Kenny Lane is shattered when an elderly neighbor is found dead, and Elsie is the one who discovers the body. As the police begin to investigate, someone in the neighborhood reveals that Elsie is actually “Mad Mabel,” the girl from the old headlines, and she quickly becomes a person of interest in the new death. At the same time, a new seven-year-old neighbor, Persephone, arrives on the street—a chatty, curious child who barrels past Elsie’s defenses and insists on befriending her, further complicating Elsie’s efforts to keep the past buried.

Interwoven with the present is the story of Mabel’s earlier life. As a child, she grows up in a seemingly privileged home overshadowed by her cruel, self-absorbed father, who blames her for a series of accidents and deaths that occur around the family. His accusations follow her into the community, turning her into a target for gossip and suspicion long before any crime is committed. The “Then” chapters trace her childhood, adolescence, and the circumstances that eventually lead to her being labeled “Mad Mabel” and sent away, though the specific details of the crime and its fallout are revealed gradually through her recollections and interviews.

As the narrative moves back and forth, Elsie is approached by two young content creators who want to tell her story via an online interview or podcast, giving her a platform to finally explain herself while also raising the stakes of what might come to light. The plot centers on the slow unspooling of what really happened in Mabel’s past, how it shaped the life she’s been living in secret on Kenny Lane, and how the renewed scrutiny—police interest, nosy neighbors, a determined child, and the lure of public confession—threatens to upend the fragile peace she’s maintained for decades, without fully revealing the ultimate answers or twists.

You and I both know that “grumpy older neighbor with a past” is basically catnip for Readers With Wrinkles. So if we were sitting across from each other with a pot of coffee between us, here’s how I’d talk you into Mad Mabel.

Because you love a complicated older woman at the center

This isn’t a side-character granny popping in with one-liners; Mabel is the story. She’s prickly, stubborn, sharp as a tack, and absolutely done with other people’s nonsense. If you’ve ever wished more books treated older women as full, messy, layered humans instead of background decoration, this one will feel like a small triumph.

It taps into the “if they only knew my past” feeling

Mabel’s carefully built quiet life on Kenny Lane sits on top of a past that could blow it all up. That tension—who you were versus who you are now—is something a lot of us feel, even if our teenage years didn’t involve national headlines. The book leans into that idea that a long life holds chapters no one around you has read yet.

It understands long-term neighbors and chosen family

You know that particular intimacy of living on the same street for decades—knowing who puts their bin out at exactly 6:03 p.m., who slams doors, who over-trims their hedges? This story gets that. The cul-de-sac isn’t just a backdrop; it’s a little ecosystem of grudges, loyalties, and unspoken history. If you’ve ever referred to “the people on our street” like a second, slightly dysfunctional family, you’ll feel right at home.

The cross-generational friendship is quietly lovely

There’s something special about the way Mabel ends up entangled with a determined little girl who refuses to be scared off by her bark. If you enjoy stories where older and younger characters collide and accidentally soften each other, that thread will tug at you. It’s not saccharine; it’s more like watching a reluctant grandparent figure appear where nobody expected one.

It mixes domestic life with just enough mystery

You get your cups of tea, neighborhood gossip, and day-to-day routines—but all of it hums over the low thrum of "What really happened back then?” If you like your reading cozy in setting but not sleepy in plot, this hits that sweet spot. It’s the kind of book you can sink into and still feel that pull to read “just one more chapter.”

It respects readers who’ve lived a little

This story assumes you understand regret, second chances, and the way one decision can echo for decades. It doesn’t talk down to you or over-explain; it trusts that you can sit with ambiguity, hold sympathy and suspicion at the same time, and appreciate a character who isn’t easy to pin down. In other words, it’s built for people who bring a lifetime of reading—and living—to the page.

Get Sally Hepworth Books

Sally Hepworth writes compulsively readable, emotionally sharp novels about families, friendships, and the secrets simmering beneath suburban perfection—perfect for readers who love their page-turners with real heart and moral complexity.

Bookshop.org was created as a socially conscious alternative to Amazon, with the goal of helping local, independent bookstores thrive. This is why Readers With Wrinkles supports their efforts. Please join us in this effort by purchasing your next read here.

Purchase Sally Hepworth books on Bookshop.org

If you loved How to Read a Book, here are some character-driven reads that should resonate.”

A Man Called Ove by Fredrik Backman
The gold standard of lovable curmudgeons, this novel follows Ove, a gruff widower who’s fed up with life and his incompetent neighbors—until a chaotic young family moves in next door and slowly, stubbornly wedges themselves into his routine. As mishaps pile up, we see the quiet heartbreak behind his rules and rants, and watch him evolve from isolated crank to reluctant community anchor.

An Elderly Lady Is Up to No Good by Helene Tursten
This darkly funny collection of stories stars Maud, an irritable, fiercely independent 88‑year‑old Swedish woman who has no family, no patience, and absolutely no qualms about “solving” her problems—sometimes permanently. On the surface she’s just a prickly old lady; underneath, she’s alarmingly resourceful, and watching her navigate (and manipulate) the world is half wicked fun, half oddly charming.

The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman
In a quiet retirement village, four septuagenarians meet weekly to pore over unsolved crimes…until a real murder lands practically on their doorstep. The club members are nosy, opinionated, and delightfully irritable about everything from technology to developers, yet their determination and surprising reserves of loyalty and courage make them deeply endearing as the case unfolds.

The One-Hundred-Year-Old Man Who Climbed Out the Window and Disappeared by Jonas Jonasson
Allan Karlsson, thoroughly unimpressed by the fuss over his 100th birthday in a nursing home, climbs out the window and disappears, stumbling into an absurd, crime‑tinged adventure. He’s cantankerous and blasé about just about everything, but as the book weaves in tales from his long, improbable life, you see the wry humor and odd generosity beneath his shrugging grumpiness.

Florence Gordon by Brian Morton
Florence is a famously prickly feminist intellectual who would like nothing more than to be left alone to write her book and sip her coffee in peace. When family and health interruptions force people into her orbit, her barbed one‑liners give way—very slowly—to moments of vulnerability and connection, revealing a woman whose severity hides deep conviction and complicated love.

How the Penguins Saved Veronica by Hazel Prior
Eighty‑something Veronica is wealthy, bossy, and utterly uninterested in other people, thank you very much—until she becomes fixated on a TV documentary about penguins and decides to travel to Antarctica. Her frosty manner meets its match in an awkward young scientist, a long‑lost relative, and a baby penguin named Pip, all of which gradually thaw her armor and nudge her into something like real connection. Read my full review here.

The Concierge by Abby Corson
Hector Harrow has worked at the Cavengreen Hotel for decades, watching guests come and go while he keeps his anxieties and opinions tightly buttoned behind a professional, somewhat crusty exterior. As he finally begins to tell the story of “what really happened” on the night of a long-ago incident, we see how trauma, loyalty, and a buried sense of responsibility have shaped this seemingly aloof older man.

Olive Kitteridge by Elizabeth Strout
Set in a small coastal town in Maine, this linked collection of stories revolves around Olive, a retired schoolteacher who’s blunt, judgmental, and often hard to like—at first. As we see her through her own eyes and through the eyes of neighbors, students, and family members, her sharp edges slowly give way to glimpses of tenderness, regret, and hard-won empathy, making her one of modern fiction’s most memorable grumpy-yet-deeply-human older women. Read my full review here.